old review from last year:
The Kiterunner, 2007
Friday, January 18, 2008 at 9:13am
The old adage, “the book is better” holds true for ‘The Kiterunner,’ yet another book turned into movie, although the least of my criticisms would be that it strayed from the original script—because it didn’t really, and perhaps therein lies its flaws. Stylistically, it lacks the finesse of a slick drama that tugs at the heart’s strings from the very first scene. Instead, the dialogue seems dry, and the adult… (show more)
The old adage, ‘the book is better’ holds true for ‘The Kiterunner,’ yet another book turned into movie, although the least of my criticisms would be that it strayed from the original script—because it didn’t really, and perhaps therein lies its flaws. Stylistically, it lacks the finesse of a slick drama that tugs at the heart’s strings from the very first scene. Instead, the dialogue seems dry, and the adult actors lack conviction. The children on the other hand, make up for these drawbacks, and the one line, For you, a thousand times over has as much a haunting tone to it when said by both Hassan, the hazara boy, and much later by Amir to Hassan’s son.
To those for whom the sport of kite-flying is a novelty concept, these scenes would certainly be most enjoyable, and even more so to those who have enjoyed this sport themselves. I myself have the fondest memories of having flown many a kite from my rooftop in my childhood home each year toward the end of winter/early spring on bright sunny afternoons. Although traditionally a sport for young boys, my father in his infinite love for his only child, albeit a girl, remained quite oblivious to this obvious fact even as he taught me the many intricacies of launching the kite, biding my time before letting it lift higher and higher–only to let it fall back to fool another nearby kite–and then to stealthily swoop under it to let the manja do the trick in cutting down the competitor! Oh, the memories… In my case, I didn’t always have someone to run down the kite, and instead let the neighborhood boys get it for themselves; still the thrill of victory was no less sweet or diminished.
But coming back to the movie, the larger themes of loyalty, betrayal and redemption at last are faithfully played out—if only the delivery didn’t lack that inexplicable je ne sais quoi quality, it might have had the desired effect of total devastation—the kind that leaves you warm all over and weak in the knees even as your heart is breaking. Yet despite depriving us of this sensation, it is still worth a watch, and if nothing else, is a good window into the world of the despicable Taliban in modern Afghanistan (now there’s an oxymoron if I ever saw one!).
–Friday, January 18, 2008
Like this:
Like Loading...